In which picture does my skin look better in?

-This question was just deleted a minute ago. I have no clue why. So I'm gonna repost and don't feel like adding more detail since I just wrote a question. Basically the first picture is in winter and the second is in summer and I got darker due to sun exposure. I've gotten complements on my current color and I'm wondering what other people think? Cuz I always kinda assumed, the lighter, the better.



December: http://s747.photobucket.com/albums/xx114鈥?/a>



Now: http://s747.photobucket.com/albums/xx114鈥?/a>Now. Your skin looks brighter and healthier.i think you look really good with a tan, it gives your skin a really nice healthy glow
i think you look better now in the summer